This week’s video was a proper budget scrap: three “analog-style” delays, all chasing that bucket brigade vibe, all under sensible money, and all bringing something slightly different to the table.
If you’ve ever looked at real vintage analogue delays and then quietly closed the tab when you saw the price, this is for you.
The Contenders
We put the Joyo Analog Delay, the Mooer Ana Echo, and the TC Electronic Bucket Brigade head-to-head. On paper they all live in a similar space — warm repeats, darker voicing, classic feel — but under the hood they’re doing things a little differently.
And that’s where it gets interesting.
Joyo Analog Delay – The Sensible All-Rounder
Let’s get this out of the way first: the Joyo isn’t a “true” bucket brigade delay. It uses a PT2399 chip with filtering to get that darker, analog-style sound rather than a genuine BBD chip.
Does that matter? Not really.
It sounds good. Really good, actually — especially for the money. It tops out around 440ms, which is plenty for most practical uses, and it covers a lot of ground. Slap-back? No problem. Subtle doubling? Easy. Slightly more ambient textures? Absolutely doable.
If I had to label it, this is probably the best all-rounder of the three. It doesn’t have the strongest personality, but it also doesn’t have many weak spots. And it’s often the cheapest of the lot, which makes it very easy to recommend if you just want “a good analog-ish delay” without overthinking it.
Mooer Ana Echo – Vintage Vibes on a Budget
The Mooer Ana Echo is the purist’s choice here. It runs a genuine MN3205 bucket brigade chip and is very deliberately inspired by the Boss DM-2 — right down to the slightly backwards-feeling control layout.
If you’ve used a DM-2 before, you’ll know what I mean.
This one tops out at around 300ms, so it’s the shortest delay time of the three. It doesn’t really excel at slap-back tones — it can do them, but it’s not where it shines. Where it does shine is in those washy, ambient, slightly murky repeats that almost become part of your core tone.
It adds character. It softens the edges. It feels vintage in the best way.
And considering what a real vintage DM-2 goes for these days — or even the Waza reissue — the Mooer is a bargain by comparison.
If you want warmth and vibe over versatility, this is probably the one that’ll grab you.
TC Electronic Bucket Brigade – Crisp, Modern Analog
Then we’ve got the TC Electronic Bucket Brigade. This one uses a modern Cool Audio BBD chip — the same family of chips you’ll find in a lot of modern analogue designs (and yes, in plenty of Behringer-owned circuits too).
The big headline here is 600ms of delay time — the longest of the three. If you're after longer, luxurious repeats, then look no further.
The repeats are noticeably crisper and more defined than the other two. Because of that clarity, this one absolutely excels at shorter slap-back tones. It blends beautifully with your dry signal without turning to mush.
On top of that, you get modulation on the repeats. Subtle wobble at shorter settings, lovely movement at longer ones. That feature alone pushes it into MXR Carbon Copy territory — just without the Carbon Copy price tag.
If you want analogue feel but with a bit more modern usability, this is a very strong option.
So… Which One?
Honestly? You’re not getting a bad pedal out of this bunch.
They all cover that bucket brigade flavour in their own way, but they each lean in a slightly different direction:
- Joyo – most versatile and budget-friendly.
- Mooer – warm, vintage, characterful.
- TC Electronic – clearer repeats, longer delay time, added modulation.
Delay is one of those effects that can be as subtle or as dramatic as you want it to be. It can sit there doing gentle doubling, it can add a bit of reverb-like space, or it can become part of the rhythmic identity of what you’re playing.
The best one here isn’t about specs — it’s about which personality fits your playing.
And at these prices, the real danger is convincing yourself you only need one.
Consider using the affiliate link if you would like to buy one:
TC Bucket Brigade
https://thmn.to/thoprod/530567?offid=1&affid=2735