Open the catalogue of any budget pedal brand and I’ll bet you there’s a Tube Screamer in it. More than likely a Klone too. I like a good Tube Screamer (I've got enough of 'em). They both have their place. If you’re after something with a bit more personality than another mid-hump green box, you need some options, right?
So here are five overdrives for £50 or under, from five different brands, each doing something a bit different. Well, four doing something different and one doing something cheaper. We’ll get to that.
Sweet Baby and Pure Sky – The Transparent Pair
The Joyo Sweet Baby gets a lot of love in the comments, and I get it. Its family tree leads back to the ProCo Rat, which is a bit like finding out your mild-mannered, cardigan-wearing uncle once fronted a thrash band. It sounds nothing like that. It’s much lower gain and far more transparent, and it just feels more boutique than it has any right to for the money. There’s a mid push in there, but it’s a very different animal from a Screamer.
The Caline Pure Sky lives in similar territory. I think it’s one of Caline’s bestsellers, and it’s built on the Timmy, so you get transparent, touch-responsive drive. The two-band EQ then makes it properly versatile. At around £25–30 new, it’s one of the cheapest on the list, and I can’t think of a good reason not to try one.
Two overdrives that do things very differently, The Sweet Baby follows the mid-range thickness of a good Tube Screamer, but in a much less obvious way. The Pure Sky is kind of does the transparent Klon thing, but again, in a not
Affordaboard Supersonic – Oasis in a Box
This is the odd one out. The Trilogy/Affordaboard FX Supersonic is chasing one very specific moment in British music: Oasis ruling the 90s charts. That sound wasn’t one amp, it was three: a Marshall, a WEM and a Vox. Blend them and you get an overdrive that is very amp-like with a fuzzy edge sitting underneath it all. You get a very 3 dimensional drive tone.
The full-colour Trilogy version is £89, and there’s a monochrome Affordaboard one for £50. Either one is a good deal tbf, they are hand-made in the UK and you could easily pay either price for something mass produced. It also supports a smaller UK builder, so it's wins all around.
Preamp Overdrive – For When You Want More Amp
The DOD 250 circuit is one of those simple, versatile designs that half the pedal world has borrowed at some point. Demon FX have crammed several flavours of it into the Preamp Overdrive, switchable with two three-way switches, and even tucked in a Yngwie-style voice. Of the five, this is the one for shoving your amp as hard as it’ll go. It's like your amp, but more. Nigel Tuffnel would dig this one.
Cinders – The Cheeky Exception
The TC Electronic Cinders is a straight-up Boss Blues Driver copy, it doesn't try to hide this fact at all. Well when I say it is a straight clone, I mean sort of. It has top-mounted jacks and true bypass where the Boss is buffered. It also costs about a third of the price, which isn't hard news to swallow. It’s gold too, which gets my approval. It’s also the most-watched pedal on this list, so clearly I’m not the only one who couldn’t resist.
Over to You
Five overdrives, not a Screamer in sight, nary a klon to be seen. I would pick a favourite here, but I own them all and use them quite regularly, so I think they all get the BPC seal of approval.
Which one’s getting your vote? Tell me in the comments. And if you’ve got a trick for dialling any of them in, share it. I’ve picked up plenty from you lot already.
Here are some affiliate links if you'd like one of your own as well:
Cinders
https://thmn.to/thoprod/400120?offid=1&affid=2735
Sweet Baby
https://thmn.to/thoprod/529958?offid=1&affid=2735
Supersonic
https://affordaboard.co.uk/browse-stock/ols/products/affordaboard-supersonic