Today we’re taking a look at a head-to-head battle between two of the most popular fuzz pedals ever to appear on the channel: the TC Electronic Rusty Fuzz and the Behringer Fuzz Bender.
Between them, these two budget-friendly fuzz boxes have racked up around 80,000 views here alone — they’ve been absolute monsters for the channel. And honestly, it makes sense. Unlike overdrives or boosts, cheap fuzz is notoriously unpredictable. Sometimes you strike gold… sometimes you get a fizzy cardboard box pretending to be a pedal. Both of these, thankfully, fall firmly into the “gold” category. They’re both vintage-leaning, silicon-style fuzzes trying to capture that classic 60s/70s fuzz attitude — but they take very different routes to get there.
TC Electronic Rusty Fuzz
The Rusty Fuzz is built around a classic three-knob layout: Fuzz, Volume, and Tone. That Tone control is a huge plus — lots of old-school fuzzes don’t bother with any EQ shaping, which makes the Rusty a bit more flexible right out of the gate.
The fuzz sweep is genuinely usable from bottom to top. You don’t run into that classic “nothing… nothing… OH NO TOO MUCH” problem. And one of its biggest strengths is how well it works into a clean amp. If you’re running a pristine platform and want to add some vintage rasp on top, the Rusty does that beautifully.
Behringer Fuzz Bender
The Fuzz Bender takes a much more stripped-back approach. Just two knobs and a mode switch — the infamous “goose mode,” as we jokingly called it in the original demo. For fairness, we kept things in standard mode today. No geese were harmed in the making of this video.
Now, the Fuzz Bender is a bit temperamental at low settings. Until you really push the fuzz knob, it gives you a starved, underpowered splutter — like the transistors are begging for electricity. Very authentic to vintage behaviour… but not exactly versatile. Once you crank it, though, it hits that snarling Tone Bender-style voice it’s going for, and that’s where it really shines.
This is a pedal that rewards playing dynamics, guitar volume roll-offs, and intentional tone control use. It doesn’t do everything — but the one thing it does do, it does very well. And just like the originals, it absolutely comes alive when you push it into an already breaking-up amp.
So which one wins?
Both pedals are fantastic in their own lanes. The Rusty Fuzz gives you flexibility, usability, and a more controlled take on vintage fuzz. The Fuzz Bender is pure attitude, raw edge, and classic Tone Bender chaos — but with the quirks that come with it.
As always, the point of these Versus videos isn’t for me to crown a winner — it’s for you to decide.
So head over to the Community tab on YouTube and cast your vote. Let everyone know which fuzz takes the crown for you.
Sonicake Fazy Sandwich – Three Fuzzes in One Tiny Box
What’s better than a fuzz pedal? Easy answer: three fuzz pedals packed into one tiny, affordable box. Sonicake are continuing their steady push into the budget mini-pedal world with the Fazy Sandwich, a follow-up to their earlier Fazy Cream fuzz pedal. Both of them share two things in common — a completely confusing name, and a surprisingly convincing fuzzy tone that won’t make your wallet cry.
The Fazy Sandwich takes the familiar fuzz recipe and spices it up with three distinct flavours of fuzz, selectable via a simple toggle switch. That means one pedal can cover a lot of ground, from tight, vintage fuzz tones to wall-of-sound doom fuzz. It’s the kind of flexibility you don’t often see at this price point, especially in a pedal small enough to fit in the palm of your hand.
On the surface, the control set is refreshingly familiar: Volume, Tone, and Fuzz. These are the core dials you’d expect on most fuzz pedals, and they’re easy enough to dial in. But the real magic lies in the three-way toggle marked V, M, and JF. Each position radically changes the EQ, gain structure, and feel of the pedal — effectively giving you three different fuzz circuits in one enclosure.
V Mode – Vintage Bite
V stands for Vintage, and it’s arguably the most traditional fuzz voice on offer. Compared to the other modes, it’s the tightest and most controlled sounding, with a focused midrange and a slightly more restrained low end.
Sonicake don’t publish detailed circuit specs, but if I were guessing, I’d say V mode is probably a silicon transistor-based design. It’s got the sharper attack and relatively high gain you often find in late ‘60s and early ‘70s silicon fuzz circuits. Germanium circuits tend to have a softer mid-range and generally are a bit lower gain, conversely.
It works well for classic rock rhythm parts, bluesy leads, or anything that needs fuzz character without getting swampy. There’s still plenty of sustain available, but the tighter EQ keeps things articulate — which is especially handy if you’re playing in a dense band mix where woolly fuzz can easily get lost.
M Mode – Modern Muscle
M stands for Modern, and here the Fazy Sandwich opens up the low end. There’s more bass content, which makes it feel bigger, looser, and more “open” than V mode. It’s still recognisably a fuzz, but there’s a touch more warmth and bloom in the notes.
This voicing shift makes M mode ideal for chunky, pentatonic-based riffing, fat power chords, and big, sustaining rhythm parts. There’s a slight sag to the attack, which gives it a chewy feel under the fingers — perfect if you like a fuzz that feels alive and reactive rather than overly precise.
It’s not quite as scooped or extreme as some “modern” fuzz voices, but it’s noticeably different from V mode. If you want more girth and a slightly more forgiving response, M mode might be your go-to.
JF Mode – Frusciante (and Doom?)
JF mode is where things get interesting. I’ll admit, when I first demoed the pedal, I didn’t immediately twig what “JF” stood for. The YouTube comments section, as always, was quick to help me out — it’s almost certainly a nod to John Frusciante of Red Hot Chili Peppers fame.
At first, that seemed odd to me. I never really thought of John as a big EHX Big Muff guy, but Sonicake’s own marketing straight up calls it the 'Muff-Style classic fuzz sound', so I think it's safe to assume where the inspiration came from for this mode.
JF mode hits you with a massive low end, scooped mids, and a thick, saturated voice. It’s a huge, sustaining fuzz sound that borders on doom territory — the kind of tone that can fill the room with a single chord. Lead lines sing effortlessly, power chords become seismic events, and there’s an almost infinite sustain available if you want it.
For me, this was the most dramatic and “in-your-face” mode of the three. It’s probably not for everyone, especially if you need your fuzz to cut through in a busy mix. But if you’re going for sheer wall-of-sound impact, JF mode delivers in spades.
It's not all about looks, but it kinda is sometimes...
Like the rest of Sonicake’s mini pedal range, the Fazy Sandwich is built into a solid, compact metal enclosure. It feels sturdy enough for gig use, and its small footprint makes it easy to squeeze onto even the most crowded pedalboard.
The mottled grey finish is a nice touch — it adds a vintage vibe without going overboard, and it’s practical too, hiding the inevitable scuffs and dings that come with regular gigging. It gives a nice subtle nod to the finish on a vintage 'face-style' fuzz without the blatant infringement route that certain big German companies tend to do, not mentioning any names of course.
It’s also about as pedalboard-friendly as fuzz gets. No fiddly secondary functions, no menus, just plug in, set your mode, tweak your three knobs, and you’re off.
Where It Fits in Your Rig
The Fazy Sandwich is flexible enough to suit a wide range of players. If you’re just starting to explore fuzz, this pedal gives you three distinct styles to experiment with — which is great for figuring out what works for your guitar, amp, and playing style.
If you’re already a fuzz connoisseur, it’s a fun and inexpensive addition to the collection. You might already own “better” examples of each fuzz style, but the convenience of having all three in one pedal can’t be overstated, especially for rehearsal or travel rigs.
It also works well as a backup fuzz — if you gig with a more expensive boutique fuzz, you can throw the Fazy Sandwich in your gig bag as a safety net. If something goes wrong mid-set, you’ve got multiple fuzz flavours ready to go in a pedal you can replace for pocket change.
Jerry Springer Moment for our Final Thoughts...
Sonicake’s Fazy Sandwich is exactly what I like to see in the budget pedal world: a simple, well-built, affordable pedal that delivers multiple usable tones without gimmicks. Each mode offers something distinct, from the tighter, more classic character of V mode, to the fat, modern punch of M mode, to the huge, scooped, wall-of-fuzz chaos of JF mode.
Is it going to replace a vintage Fuzz Face, a boutique Muff clone, or a hand-wired Tone Bender? Probably not. But that’s not the point. The Fazy Sandwich is about versatility, value, and fun. It’s a pedal you can throw on your board, tweak quickly, and trust to deliver big, satisfying fuzz sounds every time.
It’s cheap as chips, built to survive the road, and small enough to fit anywhere. If you’re fuzz-curious, this is a brilliant place to start. And if you already love fuzz, well… there’s always room for one more, right?
If you'd like to get one of your own and support the channel, here is an affiliate link. Use code budgetpedalchap for a discount too:
Fuzz is one of those effects that divides guitarists faster than a Clapton vs. Hendrix debate. Some players chase the velcro-sputter of broken electronics, while others want something smoother and more musical — something that responds to touch and volume like a living, breathing amp. I’ve tried dozens of fuzz pedals over the years, from boutique beasts to bargain-bin blunders. But the TC Electronic Rusty Fuzz? That’s one I hadn’t expected to like quite as much as I did.
So here we are, talking fuzz, tone, and one of the most affordable vintage-style boxes out there — the Rusty Fuzz — a little brown brute that showed up on my doorstep thanks to long-time channel friend and supporter Bimmo. Shout out to the legend for sending this my way!
First Impressions – More 70s Than Your Nan’s Wallpaper
The Rusty Fuzz is undeniably retro in both look and sound. TC Electronic went with a 1970s brown-and-orange finish that looks like it was ripped straight off a shag-carpeted rehearsal space wall. It's kitsch, it's charming, and it screams “vintage fuzz” before you even plug it in.
The enclosure is metal, weighty and solid, and has a no-nonsense vibe. This isn’t some plastic knock off or cost-cutting compromise — this is a pedal that feels roadworthy. Top-mounted jacks are a nice touch for those who like a tidy board. Personally? I’m not part of the top-jack cult. Give me a massive, impractical box any day — one that demands board space like a prima donna fuzz diva. On the other hand, if you’re one of those folks with a five-row pedalboard setup that could rival NASA, you’ll appreciate the design here.
What’s Under the Hood?
This is where budget fuzz pedals often fall apart — literally and figuratively.
Unlike delays or reverbs that require complex circuitry, fuzz pedals are deceptively simple. That simplicity means every single component matters. Cheaper fuzz units often use high-tolerance resistors and low-quality transistors, which can result in harsh, brittle, or flat-out uninspiring tones. With wide tolerances, they can vary massively from unit to unit too, which is an absolute pain. That’s why the market’s flooded with fuzz pedals that are fizzy without being full, or woofy without any clarity.
The Rusty Fuzz, however, bucks the trend.
From everything I’ve gathered (and heard), this is a silicon-transistor circuit that’s heavily inspired by the classic Fuzz Face. You get that aggressive upper-mid content and a sharp attack, but with a bit more gain and stability than its germanium-based forebears. Silicon is known for being less temperamental and more consistent across environments — no worrying about whether your pedal will behave differently in summer heat vs a cold rehearsal room.
Like the Classics, But With Modern Manners
The moment I plugged in, I knew this wasn't your typical budget fizz box. There’s a lovely bloom on the attack — a slightly compressed swell when you dig in, especially with single coils. With humbuckers, it’s full and muscular but never muddy.
More importantly, the Rusty Fuzz does something that a lot of cheap fuzz pedals don’t:
It reacts to your guitar’s volume knob.
Roll it back, and the fuzz gently fades into a sparkly overdrive. Push it up, and the pedal snarls. This kind of cleanup is a must-have for vintage fuzz fans, and the Rusty Fuzz nails it better than some pedals twice the price. It’s the kind of pedal that encourages playing dynamics — letting you control your tone without ever switching it off.
If you’re after gated fuzz or synthy sputters, this isn’t your pedal (they do exist on a budget, which I'll cover in other articles). But if you want classic, expressive, touch-sensitive fuzz, it delivers in spades.
In Context – Real-World Use
In the video, I ran the Rusty Fuzz through a basic amp setup and dialed it in with both single coils and humbuckers. No boost, no EQ tricks. Just the pedal, a guitar, and an amp. What you hear is what you get.
With chords, the Rusty Fuzz keeps things articulate — you don’t lose the shape of your playing even when it's drenched in dirt. Lead lines have a vintage sting, and if you like that Hendrix-at-Woodstock vibe, you’ll feel right at home.
It also stacks surprisingly well with other pedals. I’ve run it before a TS-style overdrive and after a boost, and it didn’t crumble or flub out like many lower-cost fuzzes do.
Alternative Options – Mooer & Caline on the Radar
If the Rusty Fuzz has you chasing more vintage fuzz territory, there are a couple of others to check out:
Mooer Grey Faze – Also Fuzz Face inspired, and a germanium-based alternative. Slightly softer voicing, a bit lighter gain overall, but similarly affordable. Worth a look, and I’ll be covering it in an upcoming blog post (video already live on the channel).
Caline Nasty Bear – Wild name, cool graphic, solid fuzz. This one leans a bit more toward the mid point between a Face and a Muff fuzz territory, but it has a charm of its own. Not quite as polite as the Rusty Fuzz, and probably less versatile, but it definitely gets you some vintage fuzz tones.
Both of these are great examples of how the budget fuzz scene has matured — but the Rusty Fuzz remains one of the cleanest and most usable entries.
Rusty by name, shining by nature
The Rusty Fuzz surprised me.
I don't know what I was expecting honestly, but what it did was deliver and deliver well. It might not knock a boutique \£250 fuzz off your board, but it earns its place with tone, dynamics, and a vibe that punches above its price point.
For players just getting into fuzz, it’s a brilliant entry point. For veterans, it’s a solid backup or even a go-to for live use when you want something affordable, replaceable, but still reliable. And on the used market? Absolute steal.
Shout out again to Bimmo for making this one happen — this is one of those “sleeper” pedals I wouldn’t have thought to try otherwise.
And if you’ve got a favorite budget fuzz (or horror story), let me know in the comments below — or ping me on the channel. I’ll be fuzz-deep for the foreseeable future!
If you'd like one of your own and to support the channel, consider using this affiliate link
