Fuzz titans go head-to-head!

Today we’re taking a look at a head-to-head battle between two of the most popular fuzz pedals ever to appear on the channel: the TC Electronic Rusty Fuzz and the Behringer Fuzz Bender.

Between them, these two budget-friendly fuzz boxes have racked up around 80,000 views here alone — they’ve been absolute monsters for the channel. And honestly, it makes sense. Unlike overdrives or boosts, cheap fuzz is notoriously unpredictable. Sometimes you strike gold… sometimes you get a fizzy cardboard box pretending to be a pedal. Both of these, thankfully, fall firmly into the “gold” category. They’re both vintage-leaning, silicon-style fuzzes trying to capture that classic 60s/70s fuzz attitude — but they take very different routes to get there.

TC Electronic Rusty Fuzz

The Rusty Fuzz is built around a classic three-knob layout: Fuzz, Volume, and Tone. That Tone control is a huge plus — lots of old-school fuzzes don’t bother with any EQ shaping, which makes the Rusty a bit more flexible right out of the gate.

The fuzz sweep is genuinely usable from bottom to top. You don’t run into that classic “nothing… nothing… OH NO TOO MUCH” problem. And one of its biggest strengths is how well it works into a clean amp. If you’re running a pristine platform and want to add some vintage rasp on top, the Rusty does that beautifully.

Behringer Fuzz Bender

The Fuzz Bender takes a much more stripped-back approach. Just two knobs and a mode switch — the infamous “goose mode,” as we jokingly called it in the original demo. For fairness, we kept things in standard mode today. No geese were harmed in the making of this video.

Now, the Fuzz Bender is a bit temperamental at low settings. Until you really push the fuzz knob, it gives you a starved, underpowered splutter — like the transistors are begging for electricity. Very authentic to vintage behaviour… but not exactly versatile. Once you crank it, though, it hits that snarling Tone Bender-style voice it’s going for, and that’s where it really shines.

This is a pedal that rewards playing dynamics, guitar volume roll-offs, and intentional tone control use. It doesn’t do everything — but the one thing it does do, it does very well. And just like the originals, it absolutely comes alive when you push it into an already breaking-up amp.

So which one wins?

Both pedals are fantastic in their own lanes. The Rusty Fuzz gives you flexibility, usability, and a more controlled take on vintage fuzz. The Fuzz Bender is pure attitude, raw edge, and classic Tone Bender chaos — but with the quirks that come with it.

As always, the point of these Versus videos isn’t for me to crown a winner — it’s for you to decide.

So head over to the Community tab on YouTube and cast your vote. Let everyone know which fuzz takes the crown for you.